Disclaimer: this article may contain affiliate links, and I may receive a commission on sales when you use those links, at no additional cost to you. I only recommend products I use and genuinely love.
Leash pulling is one of the most common and frustrating issues dog owners face. While many trainers rely solely on positive reinforcement, my style of balanced training (a mix of structure, rewards, and clear corrections) typically delivers faster, clearer, and more reliable results, especially for strong or stubborn dogs.
At Black Magic Dog Training, I specialize in a nuanced form of balanced dog training, combining techniques of pressure-and-release conditioning mixed with solid, consistent rewards to create lasting obedience that is kind to the dog’s mind and body. Whether you have a playful doodle or a powerful working breed, this guide will teach you step-by-step methods to stop leash pulling for good.
In This Guide, You’ll Learn:
- Why dogs pull on the leash (It’s not always just excitement. It’s often learned behavior!)
- The flaws in “just reward the good” methods (Why treats alone often fail for strong pullers.)
- Step-by-step balanced training techniques (Including leash pressure conditioning, corrections, and proper timing of rewards.)
- How fitness and proper equipment play a role (Not all collars and harnesses are equal.)
- When to seek professional help (What is normal pulling behavior, and when are the leash manners truly out of hand.)
Why Do Dogs Pull on the Leash?
Before fixing the problem, it’s important to understand why leash pulling happens:
What Causes Leash Pulling?
First and foremost, pulling is a natural instinct. Dogs explore the world through movement, and pulling gets them where they want to go faster. When paired with pushing against certain types of gear, this natural instinct for forward motion can create what is called “oppositional reflex,” which increases the dog’s drive to pull against oppositional force.
Additionally, if pulling has ever worked for your dog (e.g: resulted in reaching that tree or greeting another dog), your dog learns that pulling on leash is a predictor of a reward. This not only desensitizes the sensation of pulling, but actually pairs it by pattern conditioning to an enjoyable outcome – effectively, any time pulling works to get your dog what they want, they are more likely to pull even more in the future!
Lastly, all of these reasons can be exacerbated by excess drive and energy. If a high energy dog isn’t given both a mental and physical outlet, that energy can leak out when you’re out on your walk together.
Pulling isn’t always just a matter of “dominance” or “stubbornness”—it’s a habit that needs clear, structured training or, in some cases, retraining.
Why Positive-Only Methods Often Fail for Leash Pulling
Many trainers advocate for “stop walking when they pull” or “reward when the leash is loose.” And as a balanced dog trainer, I absolutely do incorporate these techniques into my toolkit when working leash skills with the dogs I train. However, while these can sometimes work on their own for mild cases, they often fall short for:
- Large or strong dogs (very common in Labs, Huskies, and Shepherds)
- Excitable or easily distracted dogs
- Dogs with a long history of pulling
What’s Wrong With Positive-Only for Leash Pulling?
The truth is that these passive methods often take too long to be consistently effective. These methods rely not only on absolute consistency on the part of the dog owner, but also on guarantees of environment. The owner must be able to control levels of distraction to an advanced degree, which is nearly impossible when it comes to actually setting foot outside your front door.
There’s also the matter of reinforcement in pulling.
In a dog training principle called the “variable reward schedule,” we can understand that a dog will learn to “gamble” on whether or not a behavior will get them what they want if that behavior is rewarded intermittently. Therefore, if a dog sometimes gets rewarded for pulling, such as reaching a scent they were pulling to smell, the behavior not only persists, but gets stronger.
This is true even if the reward is accidental, such as if a dog briefly overpowers its owner, pulls their handler down, or if another dog or person helps them close the gap to greet. In all those situations and more, no amount of stopping and waiting will deny the dog a reward. In the future, the dog will be more likely to pull, just in case the behavior results in the desired reward!
The last reason I don’t stick to reward-only leash training is that I like providing as much clarity to the dog as possible. Giving a dog both the “hot” as well as the “cold” on what I am looking for almost always results in faster learning, so long as the “hot” (reward) is enticing and the “cold” (pressure or correction) is fair.
How I Train Loose Leash Walking
At Black Magic Dog Training I employ a leash pulling protocol that:
- Teaches leash pressure: tension on the leash means, “I’m looking for something else,” while a light leash pop communicates what’s unacceptable.
- Rewarding compliance: praise, treats, or continued movement when the leash is loose.
- Ensuring consistency (No mixed signals—pulling never gets rewarded because the handler has the appropriate leverage for safety and control.)
Choose the Right Equipment
Not all tools are equal. At Black Magic Dog Training, I recommend one of the following tools, depending on the specific dog:
- Martingale collar: for touch-sensitive dogs or dogs with more mild pulling
- Slip lead, chain, or slip collar: for young dogs just starting in leash pressure training, as well as some adult dogs, depending on other behaviors that accompany pulling
- Prong collar: my go-to for most adult dogs of normal sensitivity levels, allowing for very fine adjustments in pressure
- Training collar: a prong collar alternative for dogs with sensitive skin, or who are “soft” to prong collar pressure. For example, I use one with my hairless Xoloitzcuintli to minimize irritation to his skin.
- Plastic prong collar options: for somewhat soft dogs or as a transitionary tool between slip leads and prong collars. Can be of low construction quality, so I typically only recommend them as a temporary step between other tools.
For training to stop leash pulling, avoid:
- Retractable leashes: as they encourage pulling by failing to communicate a clear boundary. They also have more potential breaking points and may fail if a dog pulls, which can then become a much larger issue than just leash pulling.
- “No-pull” front-clip harnesses: for their potential to negatively alter posture in dogs who pull, and because they frequently fail by allowing the dog to back up out of them
- Head halters: for the potential to torque a dog’s neck in case of pulling or rushing the end of the leash. This can be very dangerous for the dog!
How to Condition Leash Pressure for Training Leash Manners
1. When your dog pulls on the leash, apply “back pressure” to the lead by meeting the natural tension with a soft pull and release.
2. Stop moving. If your dog receives the back pressure and immediately tries to move forward again, repeat the first step again while standing still.
3. The second the leash loosen and your dog has stopped moving forward, praise and resume walking.
4. If your dog is too insistent, and continues to try to pull forward (or towards something) consistently after a few repetitions, walk away and remove your dog from the situation. This tells you that you should be starting at an “easier” level for your dog, or that there are too many distractions for your dog’s ability.
5. Repeat and scale up difficulty over time. With consistency, your dog will learn that pulling means you will stop, your dog will receive a mild consequence, and that maintaining a loose leash will result in the reward (moving forward).
Reward the Right Position
- When your dog walks beside you, even for a brief moment, or if they give you eye contact while loose-leash walking, say “Yes!” and reward.
- Use food rewards or play breaks with a toy as motivation to repeat that behavior.
Increase Distractions Gradually
- Start in a quiet area, then practice near mild distractions (e.g., your backyard, then a sidewalk).
- If your dog pulls toward something (a dog, a squirrel), gently correct and redirect your dog’s attention back to you.
Adding Formal Commands
Once your dog understands leash pressure, you can consider teaching a basic “casual heel” or “street heel”:
- Lure the dog into the desired position with a food reward. Place your food hand at your side at eye level to the dog. Start by just getting the dog into the position, and feed with both of you standing still. For small dogs it can be helpful to make a “food spoon” by freezing some peanut butter or wet food onto a mixing spoon to use as a food lure.
- Start adding movement. Have your dog come into the heel position. Instead of feeding right away, take a step or two while having your dog follow the food at eye level. Mark “Yes!” and feed.
- Add distance with practice. Take more steps, add turns, and introduce stops, all while asking your dog to follow the food next to you.
- Add the cue, saying, “Heel!” at the beginning of each repetition. Remember that once you introduce a cue, you also must “free” your dog from the behavior with a release word after the repetition.
- Start fading by no longer holding food at eye level for your dog to follow. Reward every several steps your dog walks in heel when asked, pulling rewards from a treat pouch or pocket instead of where the dog can see. Fade food rewards gradually, asking for more duration between treats over time.
- Add leash pressure when your dog is practiced. Now that your dog knows how to do a street heel, you can give your dog leash pressure for errors when you’ve asked for a heel. If your dog “forges” or gets too far ahead of you, add leash pressure and release when the dog is back in their heel. This step adds “proofing,” making the behavior more reliable with or without reward. That said, it’s still a good idea to reward now and then for continued good behavior!
Common Mistakes That Make Leash Pulling Worse
- Inconsistent corrections (Sometimes allowing pulling, sometimes not.)
- Using a harness without training (Many dogs pull harder in harnesses, as they minimize discomfort and provide something to push against.)
- Getting frustrated and yanking endlessly (This desensitizes dogs and teaches dogs to ignore leash pressure.)
How Canine Fitness Helps Leash Training
A dog with pent-up energy will always struggle with self-control. My specialization in canine fitness can help in the leash training process by:
- Draining excess energy through structured exercise.
- Building impulse control with real-world distractions and focused drills.
- Strengthening obedience and engagement through movement-based training.
- Providing tool-based context, allowing dogs to pull into harnesses for sports but using a tool such as a slip lead or prong collar to communicate, “ok, no pulling now.”
A 10-minute structured play session (fetch with rules, tug with obedience) before walks can help drain some energy from an excitable dog, making the initial training a little easier for both of you.
When to Seek Professional Help
A lot of the leash training process is just a matter of consistency and communication. However, there are definitely times that it’s a good idea to reach out to a behavioral trainer for help.
If your dog:
- Lunges aggressively at dogs/people
- Ignores your rewards or corrections completely
- Is too strong for the primary handler to comfortably train on their own
…Then it’s time for expert guidance from a professional balanced trainer. My private lessons and group training classes in western Washington specialize in fixing leash reactivity using the fair balanced methods detailed above, and can help with reactivity and aggression, powerful dogs, and dogs with a history of ineffective training methods.
Leash pulling doesn’t have to be a lifelong battle. By combining clear corrections, smart rewards, and proper exercise, you can teach your dog to walk politely—without frustration for both of you.
Need hands-on help? Contact Black Magic Dog Training for personalized leash training tailored to your dog’s needs!
